Search This Blog
Thursday, July 19, 2012
Handicapping the Presidential Election
Tuesday, July 10, 2012
Mister Roberts and the Chief
When Navy Lieutenant Thomas Heggen reported onboard the Virgo on July 12, 1944, it was the beginning of “Mister Roberts” the blockbuster Broadway show, the hit movie and, finally, a long running TV series. Of course the raw material for the comedy came from actual events aboard the Virgo (the Reluctant of show, movie and TV fame). The man who took command of the Virgo was Lieutenant Commander Herbert Randall, a Merchant Marine officer who had low regard for Navy ways. He was a bit odd, to say the least, and the crew of the Virgo capitalized on his peculiar leadership.
There was the time that the Captain decided he would have potted palm trees on the bridge of the Virgo (Reluctant). In the play, movie, and series, Mister Roberts threw the potted palm trees over the side of the ship. In real life, Thomas Heggen did the very same thing twice. It was all great fun and the audiences enjoyed the hilarity immensely. And, Heggen became wealthy and famous thanks to “Mister Roberts.”
Mister Roberts was a defiant officer and Thomas Heggen was a talented writer who attacked boredom by outwitting the clueless Captain of the Reluctant (Virgo). Another Mr. Roberts recently outwitted observers. Thought to be a man of principle and character, Chief Justice John Roberts danced on the point of a pin, not for the sake of humor, but to curry favor with the political classes of Washington, DC, and to establish his place in history.
Using serpentine logic that defies all human reason, the apparent “conservative” jurist concluded that the Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, was Constitutional. When you consider that first he had to rationalize that Obamacare was not a tax in order for the Court to have jurisdiction (tax issues cannot be considered by the Court until the tax is enacted), and then rationalize that it was a tax in order to conclude that it is Constitutional (never mind that Obamacare originated in the US Senate and the US Constitution specifically enumerates that all taxes must originate in the US House of Representatives) it makes your head spin.
No parent would accept such an unbelievable story from a teenager who comes in after their curfew, yet we are to accept such twisted and silly logic because the Chief decided that in order for the Court and himself to maintain the respect of the chattering classes he would need to rule that Obamacare was Constitutional. As it turns out, John Roberts has apparently led a privileged life as a fair-haired boy. It seems that Roberts has always landed on his feet and generally on the winning side. Here’s a brief excerpt from his Wikipedia bio…
“Roberts grew up in northern Indiana and was educated in a private school before attending Harvard College and Harvard Law School, where he was managing editor of the Harvard Law Review. After being admitted to the bar, he served as a law clerk for Judge Henry Friendly and then Justice Rehnquist before taking a position in the Attorney General's office during the Reagan Administration. He went on to serve the Reagan Administration and the George H. W. Bush administration in the Department of Justice and the Office of the White House Counsel, before spending fourteen years in private law practice. During this time, he argued thirty-nine cases before the Supreme Court.”
Jeffrey Rossen, a writer with the left-leaning Atlantic magazine, interviewed Chief Justice Roberts in July 2011 to get his views on the role of a Supreme Court Justice and the role of the Chief Justice in particular. The comments of John Roberts are telling…
“Before long, the conversation turned to judicial disappointments. ‘It’s sobering to think of the seventeen chief justices; certainly a solid majority of them have to be characterized as failures,’ Roberts said with a rueful smile. ‘The successful ones are hard to number.’ I asked him to elaborate: Why had so many chief justices been failures? Partly, Roberts explained, it was because the powers of the office are not extensive. ‘A chief justice’s authority is really quite limited, and the dynamic among all the justices is going to affect whether he can accomplish much or not,’ he said. ‘There is this convention of referring to the Taney Court, the Marshall Court, the Fuller Court, but a chief justice has the same vote that everyone else has.’ As a result, ‘the chief’s ability to get the Court to do something is really quite restrained.’”
“Some of the least successful chief justices, Roberts suggested, had faltered because they misunderstood the job, approaching it as law professors rather than as leaders of a collegial Court. Harlan Fiske Stone, a former dean of Columbia Law School, was a case in point. Stone ‘was a failure as chief, because of his misperception of what a chief justice is supposed to be,’ Roberts said, gesturing to the justices’ private conference room through an open door of his office. ‘It’s his desk out there that is separate from the conference table, and he … sat at his desk, and the others were at the table, and he almost called on them and critiqued their performances. They hated that.’ Roberts laughed. ‘As a result, he was a failure as a chief justice.’
“Fifty-four percent of decisions in the first year of the Roberts Court were unanimous. This graphic shows the percentage of written court opinions on which each pair of justices agreed with one another. In Roberts’s view, the most successful chief justices help their colleagues speak with one voice. Unanimous, or nearly unanimous, decisions are hard to overturn and contribute to the stability of the law and the continuity of the Court; by contrast, closely divided, 5–4 decisions make it harder for the public to respect the Court as an impartial institution that transcends partisan politics.
“Roberts suggested that the temperament of a chief justice can be as important as judicial philosophy in determining his success or failure. And based on the impression he made in his first year on the Court and throughout his career, Roberts seems to have many of the personal gifts and talents of the most successful and politically savvy chief justices, such as Rehnquist and John Marshall, rather than those of a heavy-handed academic like Stone.”
Do you notice anything strange about Robert’s comments? They are all egocentric; they are all about how history will record Robert’s tenure as Chief Justice of the Court. They all show a determination to be recorded as a great Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. Not one comment is in regard to the United States Constitution itself.
As I said earlier, Roberts came to the court with the appearance of being a man of high principle and high character. Unfortunately, many men and women come to Congress and to high positions in government with high principles, but are lacking the integrity needed to deflect the onslaught of temptations to compromise their character. These are men and women of high principles, but low character. They are in abundance in Washington, DC. They come to town as idealists and then succumb to the allure of privilege, attention, and fawning that is given to those who cave in when the going gets tough. I’ve come across many of these men and women in my more than 40 years in Washington, DC. Believe me, the pressure to conform, to compromise, to go along is incredible. And those who are not well grounded, both personally and professionally, capitulate rather than stand up for principle.
Clearly, Chief Justice Roberts couldn’t stand the heat. He wasn’t used to public criticism. I sympathize with him. I’ve had my name smeared on the front page of The Washington Post, and in this town, an accusation is tantamount to being guilty. It takes men of incredible character like Ronald Reagan to stand by their principles when others cut and run. I’m sad for Chief Roberts and for our country.
In my view as a layman, the first question every Supreme Court Justice should ask about every law under judicial review is, “Would any one signer of the Declaration of Independence agree that this law is Constitutional?” If a law can’t pass that muster, it’s clearly not Constitutional. If a justice has to manufacture reasons why a law is Constitutional, it’s not. If you start with a conclusion, as Roberts apparently did, you end up being a contortionist in your reasoning. If you have intellectual honesty, you simply compare the written word and intent of the Constitution with the law and see if it passes muster.
Instead of worry about whether he will go down in history as a “successful” Chief Justice, John Roberts would have done better to simply consider whether or not Obamacare is permissible under the United States Constitution. Roberts has stated that he thinks his role is to be an umpire, but his title is not umpire, it is judge. And in his role as judge the measure of performance is not his collegiality, his affability, his good humor, or his ability to glad hand. His sole measure of performance is to make a decision based on the Constitution as written and intended. There is no other standard.
Of course, Roberts is now being praised in the mainstream media as “reasonable” and “approachable” and “moderate” and “statesmanlike.” He will now get invited to all the right parties, and be hailed in all the right places as a man of intellect and moderation. In truth, with this one act of betraying the Founders and the Constitution he has established himself as a failure, an anathema to the Founders and to the principles upon which our nation was created.
If you have to use twisted logic to come up with a decision, you can bet in advance that it is wrong. With this one convoluted decision, John Roberts has opened the floodgates to ever growing, ever more powerful, ever more tyrannical government. He, along with the misguided judges who have no respect whatsoever for the Constitution, has smashed any limits whatsoever on Government power.
Frankly, even if the next Congress repeals Obamacare (very hard to do), it does not change the precedent that John Roberts and the majority have established that the Government has unlimited power over the lives of its citizens. What an awful legacy John Roberts has.
Liberals and radicals are celebrating a great victory in the ruling for Obamacare, but no one won. All Americans are losers, especially future generations. Like Nero fiddling while Rome burned, only fools celebrate the demise of individual freedom. The idea that somehow we as individuals have “progressed to a higher ethic,” as progressive/liberal founder Richard T. Ely proclaimed, is ludicrous. This simple understanding of human nature was held by the Founders, “Because all people have sinned, they have fallen short of God's glory” (Romans 3:23). It is what guided them to create a government that limited man’s power. When that power is unrestrained human freedom dies and slowly, but surely is replaced by the shackles of tyranny. Liberalism’s fatal flaw is succumbing to the Devil’s lure in Genesis 3:5 “You’ll be like God.” It is the original sin, the one that leads to all sorts evil acts against others. When they substitute their human wisdom for Godly wisdom, God laughs. “The wisdom of this world is nonsense in God’s sight.” (1 Corinthians 3:19)
The good news is this, “God rules the nations. He sits upon his holy throne.” (Psalm 47:8) And because he is a God of love we can, “Give thanks to the God of heaven because his mercy endures forever.” (Psalm 136:26). If it is God’s will, we will triumph, not only this November at the polls, but by reversing the downhill course our nation is on so that our children and grandchildren may enjoy this very special land of freedom that you and I were blessed to be born in. May God bless America with the spiritual insight that guided the Founders to create a nation unique and exceptional in the annals of history.Wednesday, July 4, 2012
Runnymede, Romans & Revolution
The King did not, of course, volunteer to surrender his power over the lives of Englishmen, but was forced to do so by powerful English barons who sought to limit his powers. Of course, those with political power never willingly reduce their powers over the lives of others. In fact, they always seek to expand their power over others under the guise of providing help and assistance. The end result is always the same, less freedom for the individual and more power for the government bureaucrats and politicians. And as big government programs like Obamacare are enacted the politicians become once again rulers and masters of the people, not their servants as the American Founders intended. It is the Founder’s view turned upside down.
When the Pilgrims left England for the New World they brought with them the Massachusetts Bay Company charter that stated the colonists would “have and enjoy all liberties and immunities of free and natural subjects.” Similarly, the Virginia Charter stated that the colonists would have all “liberties, franchises and immunities” as if they had been born in England. The colonies that came later followed their example.
America’s Founders were well aware of their rights as Englishmen as guaranteed under the Magna Carta. In fact, they were proud to be English and were loyal English citizens. And while they issued a Declaration of Independence from England on July 4, 1776 it was in reality King George III who dissolved the bond between the colonies and England when he violated the Magna Carta by treating the Colonists as less than English citizens. When he denied the Colonists their rights as Englishmen he put himself above the law and thereby took himself outside the law. He effectively delegitimized his authority over the American colonists.
The Founders did not issue their Declaration of Independence without a great deal of deliberation and concern. These were well read men and the book they relied upon the most was the Bible. Nearly half of the signers of the Declaration of Independence had attended a Christian seminary. The vast majority of the rest professed to be followers of the Christian faith. As Bible students they were well aware of Saint Paul’s admonition in regard to government as written in the book of Romans, Chapter 13…
1Every person should obey the government in power. No government would exist if it hadn't been established by God. The governments which exist have been put in place by God. 2Therefore, whoever resists the government opposes what God has established. Those who resist will bring punishment on themselves. 3People who do what is right don't have to be afraid of the government. But people who do what is wrong should be afraid of it. Would you like to live without being afraid of the government? Do what is right, and it will praise you. 4The government is God's servant working for your good. But if you do what is wrong, you should be afraid. The government has the right to carry out the death sentence. It is God's servant, an avenger to execute God's anger on anyone who does what is wrong. 5Therefore, it is necessary for you to obey, not only because you're afraid of God's anger but also because of your own conscience. 6That is also why you pay your taxes. People in the government are God's servants while they do the work he has given them. 7Pay everyone whatever you owe them. If you owe taxes, pay them. If you owe tolls, pay them. If you owe someone respect, respect that person. If you owe someone honor, honor that person.
Paul’s command is very unambiguous, so how did these Christian believers justify issuing a Declaration of Independence from England and from King George III in particular? After all, Paul wrote Romans 13: 1-7 at the time Nero sat on the throne of Rome. It is hard to imagine a more vicious, more tyranical ruler than Nero. If Christians were to obey the Godless Nero, then shouldn’t they have obeyed the British King, no matter how corrupt and oppressive it was? Certainly the signers of the Declaration of Independence must have agonized over their decision go forward with their Declaration.
One would certainly not have to go through the convoluted reasoning of Chief Justice John Roberts went through to rationalize Obamacare as within the US Constitution to justify such a Declaration. If in fact the Magna Carta established the rule of law and put the law above the King rather than the King above the law, then it was clearly King George III who dissolved the ties to the England, not the Colonists. It was King George III who violated Romans 13 when he refused to submit himself to the Magna Carta. After all a government of laws means that the law is superior to any man and that those in office are servants and those who elect them are their masters. The Colonists did not, of course, elect the King, but neither was the King above the law. When he violated the Magna Carta, he dissolved the political bond that existed between England and the American Colonialists.
The Founders made their case in the Declaration of Independence states…
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal [under the law], that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed…”
The Founders assert, on the basis of the Magna Carta, that the King’s powers are derived “from the consent of the governed.” In other words, if the King goes beyond the Magna Carta or violates the Magna Carta he has dissolved his own powers.
After issuing the Declaration of Independence the Americans sought to create a new government wherein the law was firmly established to be above the leaders. The leaders were to be public servants and the people were the masters. That is the way it is supposed to be today. Presidents, Supreme Court Justices, Senators, Congressman and bureaucrats of various stripes and origins are servants, not masters. They derive their powers from the “consent of the governed”—you and me.
The government has no legitimate power except that granted to it by its citizens. It has no wealth except that which it provided it through the labor, risk, innovation and hard work of those who produce goods and services. The money that it issues represents the wealth of those of its citizens who produce those goods and services. The land that the government “owns” is the property of the people, not of government itself. The value of that land was purchased with dollars representing the wealth of private citizens.
This week we celebrate the American Revolution, a grand and glorious event that had its origin in the Founders of our nation. They were men of great courage, great foresight and great understanding. They were wise because their wisdom originated with the Bible, the source of all true wisdom. It was not a matter of their education or their intelligence that enabled them to create a new form of government entirely new in the annals of history. It was their understanding of human nature, which they derived from reading the Bible, that gave them the wisdom to limit the power of government over the lives of its citizens.
But crafty, evil by nature men have, over the period of more than 225 years, sought to undermine the wisdom of the Founders. Instead of understanding human nature and the importance of limiting government power, they seek to expand government power and thus toy with tyranny. The America our Founders envisioned and tried to establish was one that limited the power of government over the individual. It was a nation that valued freedom over the enslavement of government. It was a republic that was designed not to do things for its citizens, but to let them live free to seek their dreams and to fail and succeed as their hard work, innovation, skills and God’s blessings allowed them.
It was this dream that drew millions around the globe to its torch of freedom. It was freedom that allowed God fearing people to enjoy a degree of human freedom never before enjoyed in the history of the world. And it was the Bill of Rights that kept government from stealing their freedom.
This is the America that the Founder’s strived for, and yet today, there are those who put their hopes in government to do things for them—to provide for their retirement, to provide for their health care, to choose what food they shall eat, to choose what car they shall drive, to decide where the fruits of their labors shall be spent. And, of course, those in government are all too willing to accommodate them as they steal their freedom bit by bit, turning the land of liberty into but a fading shadow of the dream of the Founders.
This year, may we not only celebrate the bold fidelity of our Founders in striving for freedom, but also re-dedicate ourselves to their dream of limited government and maximum individual freedom. May God grant us the wisdom, the determination, and the perseverance we need to turn the tide on those who would enslave us. Happy Independence Day!
Friday, June 29, 2012
Fast & Furious vs. Watergate
Well, let’s look at the record. On April 16, 2009, newly inaugurated President Barack Obama, traveled to Mexico to meet with Mexican President Felipe Calderon. At that meeting President Obama said…
“This war is being waged with guns purchased not here but in the United States… more than 90 percent of the guns recovered in Mexico come from the United States, many from gun shops that lay in our shared border. So we have responsibilities as well.”Really, that’s the source of all the guns on the border? Well if it is the fault of the United States we should curtail gun sales, right? Sure, the facts don’t back up the accusation, but we can fix that. We could arrange for the Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and Firearms (ATF) and US Department of Justice to start a secret program whose ostensible purpose is to catch the Mexican gang members. We’ll make sure hundreds of high powered guns and ammunition make it into the hands of Mexican Drug Lords. We’ll do this by pressuring legitimate gun sellers in the United States to sell these weapons to suspected Mexican gang leaders. Then we’ll trace the guns back to the drug leaders and presto, we’ll stop the killing.
Of course, the real purpose of this secret plan which we’ll call something like “Operation Fast & Furious” is to validate the assertion that it is American gun sellers who are responsible for all the mayhem and bloodshed on the border. We won’t really try to trace the guns or use them to find Drug Lords, we’ll just let the killing increase dramatically and get so bad that there will be a public outcry to shut down the gun sellers along the border and all across the nation. Finally, once and for all, we will start getting guns out of the hands of American citizens. “Operation Fast & Furious” is, of course, just the first step.
We can count on the news media to get on board. They will pick up the chant, “American guns are the cause of violence on the border.” The stage will be set. And so “Operation Fast & Furious” got underway in the Fall of 2009. At first, things were going along swimmingly. A brilliant political plan hatched in the Obama White House to stop gun sales to private individuals was well underway.
But on December 15, 2010, Operation Fast & Furious began to unravel. That’s the day that U.S. Border agent, Brian Terry, was killed by guns sold through Operation Fast & Furious. At first his death was reported as just another killing on the border and for many months thereafter, the ATF and the DOJ were able to keep the lid on the source of the weapon that killed Brian Terry. The killing did not apparently dim the enthusiasm of President Obama for Operation Fast & Furious.
“On March 30, [2011] the 30th anniversary of the assassination attempt on President Ronald Reagan, Jim Brady, who sustained a debilitating head wound in the attack, and his wife, Sarah, came to Capitol Hill to push for a ban on the controversial "large magazines." Brady, for whom the law requiring background checks on handgun purchasers is named, then met with White House press secretary Jay Carney. During the meeting, President Obama dropped in and, according to Sarah Brady, brought up the issue of gun control, ‘to fill us in that it was very much on his agenda,’ she said.You can almost hear the President’s excitement and enthusiasm bubbling over. Years ago the Democrats made a political decision to stop their campaign against private gun ownership. It was a political loser and they could not get elected if they continued their drive to end private gun ownership in America. But that political calculation never set well with those on the far left, like Barack Obama and his pal, Bill Ayres. Like all leftists throughout history, they do not want guns in the hands of private citizens. Power to the people does not include wealth, property or guns. It’s just a slogan to keep their uninformed followers in line. They like having guns in the hands of the police and the army, (both of which they control) but not in the hands of individual Americans.
‘I just want you to know that we are working on it,’ Brady recalled the president telling them. ‘We have to go through a few processes, but under the radar.’
But the smart politicos in the White House, encouraged by our very smart President, were about to put one over on those country bumpkins who still believed in the Constitution. They were going to create a hue and cry as had never been heard before to end private gun sales. It was almost too good to be true. Surely the death of one border agent couldn’t derail such a magnificent plan. After all, such collateral damage is sometimes necessary to accomplish important political objectives. The good of the masses is far more important than just one life. Just ask Joseph Stalin.
But in December 2011, the dam burst. Speaking to FOX News, ATF Special Agent John Dodson said,
“I am here today because it’s been a year since the first hearing and Brian Terry’s family still doesn’t have answers."Dodson blew the whistle on Operation Fast & Furious.
Of course the news media jumped right on this story. Sadly, that’s not what happened. They almost entirely ignored the story. In fact, as the story grew and became bigger and bigger, NBC News allocated just 10 seconds of one evening news broadcast to coverage of the story, tossing it aside as “politics.” It wasn’t politics to Brian Terry and his family. Even today, after months of stonewalling by US Attorney General Eric Holder, the media does its best to ignore this story. President Obama did his utmost to keep investigators from getting hold of all the documents related to this story by asserting Executive Privilege, but even this has not awakened the mainstream news media to perhaps the biggest White House scandal in American history.
Let’s see. The Nixon folks called Watergate a tempest in a teapot and “just politics.” President Nixon also asserted Executive Privilege. Even though Attorney General Holder has been held in contempt by a bipartisan coalition of the United States House of Representatives, the compliant news media continues to spin the Fast & Furious scandal as “just politics.” Calls for an independent prosecutor are studiously ignored and the media have joined in the stonewalling.
White House Press Secretary, Jay Carney, is right when he says that Operation Fast & Furious is nothing like Watergate. No one died as a result of Watergate. In fact, we may learn when the truth eventually comes out that Watergate was peanuts compared to this bloody scandal.
Meanwhile, every effort is being made to discredit, distort and delay any investigation into Operation Fast & Furious. Is that the shredders running overtime at the White House that I hear, destroying any incriminating e-mails, notes, letters, or other documentation?
The question is, what did the President know and when did he know it? Was he referring to Operation Fast & Furious when he said that he was doing something to get rid of all the guns “under the radar.” If not, what was he referring to? Was the President in on the plan from the beginning, or just an enthusiastic supporter as the plan unfolded?
This is a White House that has repeatedly proven that it has total disregard for the law. They only see laws as an impediment doing whatever they want to do. Or as the President famously said, “I can’t wait for Congress.” Whether it is Congress or the Constitution, both are just obstacles to a White House that finds more to like about dictators such as Hugo Chavez and Fidel Castro than they do the Founders of this nation.
Methinks the President will be fortunate to lose the election and retire to a very nice pension and endless rounds of golf and relaxation, rather than the possibility of facing impeachment and conviction for his role in the cover-up of Operation Fast & Furious. If I were President Obama I’d choose this election year to get out of Dodge, before his house of cards collapses entirely. No one wants to see any President of the United States in the docket. Stay tuned, the whole story is yet to be told.
Thursday, June 21, 2012
Misunderstanding Citizens United—Intentional Dissembling or Ignorance?
Tuesday, June 12, 2012
A Courageous Book
In 2009, shortly after assuming his post as Attorney General of the United States, Eric Holder said that Americans are "essentially a nation of cowards" when it comes to discussing race issues. While I don’t think the new book by Harry Stein (No Matter What…They’ll Call This Book Racist, Encounter Books 2012) is what Eric Holder had in mind, it is a frank, honest, and courageous discussion of the issue of race in 21st century America. What Holder means by calling Americans cowards is that he expects white Americans to publicly acknowledge the fact that they are racist and the United States of America is a racist nation. He doesn’t seek an honest discussion, but rather he seeks admission of guilt by white folks that they are the sole cause of black problems in America. What he seeks is the wholesale conversion of all Americans to his way of thinking.
Frankly, Eric Holder and Barack Obama can’t afford an honest discussion of the issues facing black Americans. Without the smears and name-calling, black Americans would discover that they have a lot more in common morally, spiritually and politically with conservatives than they do with liberals like Holder and Obama.
As Stein puts it…
“…for the world as they see it to make sense, racism must be ever-present as a root cause, the all-purpose explanation for every problem faced by minorities in America. In fact, the very last thing Holder wants is a serious examination of why, in this freest and most prosperous of nations, so many minorities continue to lag economically and educationally or why rates of criminality in the inner cities are so appallingly high.”
Harry Stein was a liberal until not too long ago. That’s the way he grew up and that’s what he was taught by his parents, school and college. His friends were liberals, he read liberal publications, he agreed with liberal television reporters, and he thought conservatives were nuts. And then he was hit by a bolt of reality that he discusses in his book. That’s when he became a conservative.
I heard several talk show hosts talk about Stein’s new book [his first book as a conservative was How I Joined the Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy (and Found Inner Peace)]. Stein has a great sense of humor and is absolutely fearless. Obviously he also likes long titles for his books.
When Stein told a colleague that he was going to write No Matter What…They’ll Call This Book Racist he advised him not to. In fact, his friend said they will destroy you. But clearly, Harry Stein is not easily intimidated.
You’ll learn in the book where the title came from. Hint…it has something to do with a Tea Party rally. The book is appropriately dedicated “To black conservatives everywhere, shock troops in the battle for America’s soul.” As Stein documents, the vitriol fired at black conservatives is many, many times worse than the name calling directed at white conservatives. The left is very threatened by black conservatives. Their growing ranks threatens the false narrative of the left that all conservatives are racists and are the enemy of black Americans.
Here are just a few brief excerpts from Stein’s book…
“The idea that it is racism that has millions of underclass blacks mired generation after generation in physical and spiritual poverty is not just false, but the greatest impediment to fundamentally altering that dreadful state of affairs. What must be faced—above all, by its victims—is that the real problem is a culture of destructive attitudes and behaviors that denies those in its grip the means of escape.”
Stein asserts…
“Today the vast majority of Americans, almost all of us, embrace [Dr. Martin Luther] King’s admonition to judge others solely by ‘the content of their character.’”
And…
“…we have embraced true racial tolerance—which is to say, indifference to skin color—more fully than any other people on earth.”
You can almost hear the left howling in agony.
Stein ridicules Morris Dees of the far left Southern Poverty Law Center for labeling the Family Research Council and the Federation of American Immigration Reform as “hate” groups. He also takes on Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson, who he dubs the “the Godfather of Shakedowns.”
With the sharpness of a surgeon’s scalpel he exposes the double standards of liberals and their closed minded approach to real solutions to black poverty. He lampoons them for continuing with the same failed policies that they have followed for the last 50 years, expecting different results.
You may not agree Stein or not, the points he raises in this book deserve a reasoned, non-emotional response, even if liberals believe he is all wrong. Being wrong and suggesting alternate solutions like school choice, the elimination of minimum wage laws, etc. does not make someone a racist. When the term racist is hurled wildly about without genuine evidence or cause, the only purpose is to obfuscate and end a civil discourse on the race issue. One must conclude that the purpose is not to solve problems, but to continue them for personal and political reasons.
What Stein has offered is an honest and frank discussion of the issues that face black Americans mired in poverty. If and only if we can have such an open and candid discussion of alternatives to the past failed policies of the left is there any chance that the desperation and despair of the poor can be turned into real hope and opportunity. The only thing standing in the way of real solutions is liberal opportunists and politicians who benefit from the status quo.
Buy and read this book.
Thursday, June 7, 2012
In Denial
We are told that there are six stages in the grief process—shock, denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and finally, acceptance of reality. Ever since the 2010 election, liberals and Democrats (a redundancy, I know) have been in denial. First, they were shocked by the outcome of the 2010 election. They couldn’t believe what happened. They said the voters did not understand. They said the uninformed citizens of America had a tantrum. Senator Harry Reid, leader of the US Senate, called tea party members who believe in Constitutional government radicals. Then the news media called the tea party folks racists. They were called dangerous.
Then came the denial stage. It wasn’t a sea change election of voter anger with politicians who had passed Obamacare against the wishes of 70% of the American people, it was just a “throw the incumbents out” election due to the fact that the economy was in the tank. In other words, it was a mindless “throw the rascals out” sentiment that caused Democrat losses. The Democrats and the media studiously ignored the fact that it wasn’t just a landslide victory for the Republicans in the House of Representatives, with the GOP making great gains in the Senate, it was a devastating top-to-bottom Democrat shellacking.
Found on the back pages of the newspapers was the grudging reporting of the fact that the Republicans and especially conservatives gained more than 700 seats in the state legislatures, they captured multiple governorships, and they elected Republican majorities in city council and county government races in long held safe Democratic strongholds. In Buchanan County, Missouri, Republicans had never held a majority of offices. In 2010 they won every contested race. In North Carolina the GOP had never had control of the state legislature until 2010. The scope and depth of the 2010 election victory by the GOP was similar in scope to the 1930 election victory by the Democrats. More important, it wasn’t just a Republican victory, it was a clear conservative victory. In race after race for the US Senate and the US House, liberal RINO Republicans were replaced in primaries by stout conservative Republicans in the mold of Representative Michele Bachmann and Senator Jim DeMint.
To put it into perspective, in 1928 Republican Herbert Hoover was elected in a landslide with 58.2% of the popular vote and 83.6% of the electoral vote. It was a smashing victory, but it was also the end of an era of Republican dominance. For the remainder of the 20th century, with only a few exceptions (most notably the Reagan era) the Democratic Party and the liberal ideology has dominated public policy.
In November of 2008 Barack Obama was elected President with 52.9% of the popular vote and 67.8% of the electoral vote. The Democrats gained 21 additional seats in the House and 7 additional seats in the Senate giving them a super majority and ensuring they could pass whatever legislation they wished, including socialized medicine, under the moniker Obamacare.
There are great parallels to the sea change elections of 1930 and 1932 to those of 2010 and 2012. In October of 1929 the stock market crashed and in 1930 the Democrats gained 52 seats in the United States House of Representatives. In 2010, after Obamacare was passed with some extra-parliamentary maneuvers, the Republicans gained 63 seats in the House of Representatives. In 1932, with Franklin D. Roosevelt at the head of the ticket, the Democrats gained more than 100 additional seats in the House of Representatives, putting them almost permanently in the public policy driver’s seat, with control of both the US Senate and the US House of Representatives.
In 1932 the Democrats completed the top to bottom sweep that began in 1930. The Republican Party was rejected by the American people from the courthouse to the White House. Republicans were in full retreat and liberalism was for the first time in American history advancing on every front. It had made a cameo appearance with the election of Woodrow Wilson in 1912 who won 41.8% of the popular vote thanks to a split in the Republican Party led by Theodore Roosevelt. Wilson’s election was in many ways similar to the election of Bill Clinton in 1992, who received just 43% of the popular vote. Like Wilson before him, Clinton benefited by a split Republican vote due to the third party candidacy of Ross Perot.
I believe the liberal ideology and the Democratic Party reached its apogee with the election of Barack Obama in 2008. By overreaching and exposing their redistributionist agenda, the Democrats exposed their true colors as Marxist wannabes. The Democrats spent with abandon, taking the nation to the brink of bankruptcy. For the first time in history, Standard and Poors downgraded US Bonds from AAA to AA+. It wasn’t quite junk bond status, but it was on the road to it.
In response to their poor stewardship, the American people revolted at the ballot box in 2010. But even after the results were in, the Democrats were still in denial about the tea party revolt and the sea change losses of 2010. They rationalized that the downgrade was due solely to the reluctance of tea party members of congress to increase the debt ceiling. By the time 2011 rolled around, the Democrats had convinced themselves that 2010 was just a “change election” and that 2012 would be another “change election” with Nancy Pelosi back in charge as Speaker of the House of Representatives, and the Democrats hanging on to their majority in the US Senate. They announced that the tea party was dead and that it had been replaced by the “occupy” revolt that was the true wave of the future. From reading the newspaper and watching TV, the 2010 election never happened, it was just a mirage and things would be back to normal with the Democrats in control again after 2012.
But as grief counselors will tell you, just denying something doesn’t make it reality. The huge victory achieved by Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker this week is a harbinger of what’s ahead for the Democrats in November 2012. Remember this is Wisconsin, one of the most liberal states in the nation. This is the state where radicals blew up a building and killed a graduate student in the 1960s, it is the home of Russ Feingold, Tammy Baldwin, and scores of nutty liberal professors. After spending tens of millions of dollars to recall state senators and to recall Governor Walker the liberals are still in denial. It just can’t be true. The Republicans outspent us, it was outside money, etc. They can’t accept the fact that their liberal ideology is unpopular with the American people, even in Wisconsin!
The next step in the grief process will come on November 7, the day after the election. Dick Morris did a study of the uncommitted vote in presidential elections over the past 50+ years. What he found is that with the exception of Ronald Reagan in 1984, there was a consistent pattern. The challenger to an incumbent President received all of the undecided vote in every election. In fact, in one case, the challenger received all of the undecided vote plus 2% of the vote leaning toward the incumbent.
There is absolutely no reason to believe that the 2012 election will not follow this same pattern, especially after the results of the Scott Walker recall election in Wisconsin. Using the current poll results and applying this criterion, Barack Obama will win just 10 states plus the District of Columbia in 2012. Mitt Romney will win 40 states in a landslide election gaining more than 55% of the popular vote. Even the 10 state win for Obama is shaky. Amazingly, New York State is in play with Obama having just a .5% edge over Romney.
Following the election pattern of FDR’s sweeping victory in 1932, the Romney victory is sure to have a strong down ticket pull. It will likely to add Republican seats in the US House, achieve a near super majority in the US Senate, pick up seats in state legislatures, elect more Republican Governors, and elect more Republican majorities in city and county governments. More importantly, it will spell the end of the disastrous liberal era in American politics.
And on Wednesday, November 7, the next step in the grief process will begin for the Democrats—anger. Liberals already seem to have a tendency toward anger and unhappiness. Losing an election and losing control may well put them over the edge. In Wisconsin there are online threats to assassinate Governor Walker. The left seems to be comfortable with violence. They rationalize it and excuse it when it is directed at conservatives. The anger will be followed quickly by the next step in the grief process—bargaining. The Democrats and their steadfast allies in the news media will plead that it is the responsible thing for Republicans to do to compromise with the Democrats. It’s never the responsibility of Democrats to compromise, but it’s always the responsibility of Republicans to compromise.
After the bargaining fails, Democrats and liberals will suffer from depression, the penultimate stage in the grief process. Can it really be true that the American people reject our redistributionist philosophy? Do Americans really believe in opportunity, not government guaranteed results? Are Americans really more conservative in their outlook than they are liberal? Do they really reject catastrophic man caused climate change? Do they really believe in God?
Finally, reality will set in. It really is over. The 90 year illusion that citizens can receive something for nothing without losing individual freedom will come to a close. The reality that imperfect people cannot create a perfect society, as our Founders well understood, will penetrate the consciousness of informed Americans. It won’t be a perfect country or an ideal country, but it will be once again a shining city on a hill holding aloft the lamp of freedom to the world. Prosperity, faith, personal compassion, racial harmony, and opportunity for all Americans will have an opportunity to become reality in the new American century.